Brokerage Account vs. High-Yield Savings: Which One Fits Your Financial Goals?

Brokerage accounts and high-yield savings accounts are both excellent tools you can use to secure financial well-being. Most people can benefit from having both types of accounts. The important thing is knowing when, why, and how to use each of them.

There are key differences between a brokerage account vs. a high-yield savings account. It’s generally easier to access funds in savings accounts, but they offer fewer opportunities for significant growth. It’s important to understand the potential benefits, drawbacks, and risks associated with each type of account so you can work toward maximizing your savings and building long-term wealth and financial security.

Understanding High-Yield Savings and Brokerage Accounts

What Is a High-Yield Savings Account (HYSA)?

A high-yield savings account is a bank account that provides a higher interest rate, or annual percentage yield (APY), compared to traditional savings accounts or checking accounts. It’s not uncommon for the APY of a HYSA to exceed five times the average APY of a traditional savings account.

What Is a Brokerage Account?

A brokerage account is a type of non-retirement investment account that allows you to purchase stocks, bonds, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and other securities. This provides an opportunity to grow your money faster than with a HYSA. However, it also presents the risk of losing money depending on the performance of your investments.

Liquidity and Accessibility: Which Account Is Easier to Use?

Withdrawal Restrictions on High-Yield Savings Accounts

You can typically withdraw funds from a HYSA at any time via ACH transfers, ATM withdrawals, or checks, just like you can with traditional banking accounts. That’s why a HYSA is an ideal choice for an emergency fund. You can take advantage of higher interest rates while maintaining the liquidity of your funds in the case of an unforeseen event like an unexpected car repair, a medical emergency, or loss of employment.

However, some financial institutions have minimum balance savings restrictions or offer higher APYs if your account balance exceeds a certain amount. For example, a bank may offer a higher rate for savings accounts with balances of at least $25,000, while lower balances earn less interest per month. It’s more common to find HYSAs offered by online banks, so you may be restricted in your ability to visit a branch in person.

Liquidity and Access in Brokerage Accounts

Uninvested cash in a brokerage account is highly liquid. You can usually withdraw cash with a simple transfer to a separate bank account. However, funds you used to buy investment holdings like stocks, ETFs, and bonds are not easily accessible. You need to sell these investments before you can access the associated money.

Depending on how long you held the investment for and your taxable household income, you may also have to pay capital gains taxes on your earnings when you sell the security.

Interest Rates and Potential Returns: Which Option Offers More Growth?

HYSA Interest Rates vs. Market Returns in Brokerage Accounts

The potential to grow your wealth in a HYSA or a brokerage account depends on a few factors, including:

• How much money you’re able to contribute to savings or investments
• The APY on your high-yield savings account
• The performance of the individual holdings in your brokerage account
• Market fluctuations and conditions

With a HYSA, you only have two ways to grow your funds: additional contributions and earned interest. With a brokerage investment account, you may earn interest on uninvested cash and benefit from capital appreciation (increases in the market value of your funds) as well as dividend distributions.

Long-Term Growth vs. Stability: Choosing the Right Strategy

While investment returns are never guaranteed, the potential for long-term growth is typically much higher with a brokerage account vs. a high-yield savings account — but only if you make careful, long-term investing decisions with your money market funds. While the possible upside is higher, you also take on significantly more risk when you invest your money via a brokerage account.

Investments made through money market accounts should be well-researched and carefully considered. It’s never a good idea to invest money you may need in the near future. HYSAs generally offer more stability and less risk, although the potential for growth is more limited. It's also worth exploring a brokerage account vs. high-yield CDs if you're looking for stable growth.

Risk and Safety: How Secure Are Your Funds?

FDIC Insurance and Stability of High-Yield Savings Accounts

Like regular savings accounts at traditional banks, HYSA deposits at reputable financial institutions are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) up to $250,000 per depositor. As long as your money remains in the bank, the cash and the interest it incurs will be protected.

Market Risks and Investment Volatility in Brokerage Accounts

Unlike HYSAs, brokerage accounts are not insured by the FDIC. Many brokerage accounts are insured by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) up to $500,000 in cash and securities. However, the SIPC does not protect against declining securities or fluctuations in the market.

When To Use a High-Yield Savings Account vs. a Brokerage Account

If you’re trying to build an emergency fund or you need short-term savings to reach a specific financial goal, such as saving for a down payment on a home or buying a new car, a HYSA is probably a better option. If you want to build long-term wealth and achieve financial security and independence, you may benefit more from a brokerage account.

The right strategy for you depends on a number of factors:

• Your current savings, debts, and investments
• Your specific financial goals and concerns
• Your time horizon
• Your risk tolerance
• Current HYSA interest rates and market conditions
• Your level of financial education

In general, it’s always a good idea to make sure you have emergency savings that are easily accessible in case you’re suddenly hit with an unforeseen financial burden. Once you have a solid emergency fund, making safe investments in a retirement account or brokerage account is an excellent way to achieve your long-term financial goals.

Making the Right Financial Choice for Your Goals

Both HYSAs and brokerage accounts can be powerful financial tools. Each type of account has unique benefits and applications.

Generally, a HYSA is preferable for those looking to save money in a secure, easily accessible account and earn some interest. Brokerage accounts are best suited for growing wealth over time, keeping up with inflation, and investing in the broader economy.

Explore the best savings accounts at MoneyAtlas and strengthen your financial understanding and confidence.